Sarbit U.S. Equity Fund Commentary
Portfolio Sub-Advisor: Sarbit Advisory Services Inc.
Fund Commentary - December 31, 2011
The Fund underperformed the benchmark during 2011. During the
year, the Fund had an overweight position in Consumer
Discretionary, Consumer Staples and Telecommunications Services
sectors, and a market weight in Financials sector compared to the
benchmark. The Fund was underweight the Energy, Health Care,
Industrials, Materials and Utilities sectors. However, the
Portfolio Sub-Advisor focuses on a bottom-up investment approach,
taking positions in winning companies at discounted prices, with
minimal attention paid to sector allocation.
The Portfolio Sub-Advisor strongly believes in holding a
concentrated position in few names. The top five holdings - Six
Flags Entertainment Corp., CVS Caremark Corp., Berkshire Hathaway
Inc., Iconix Brand Group, Inc. and Coinstar Inc. - make up almost
50% of the Fund's weightings. The Portfolio Sub-Advisor believes
these companies have measurable qualities that make them strong
candidates to increase in value.
Detracting from Fund performance over the course of the year were
holdings in Gap Inc., Smart Technologies Inc. and Iconix Brand
Group, Inc. Gap Inc. continues to be well-managed but the
competition is fierce in the consumer clothing retail market.
Revenue remained disappointingly flat and the Portfolio Sub-Advisor
decided to liquidate the position and allocate capital to more
promising investments. More than half of the decline in the Fund
was due to the decrease in share price of Smart Technologies Inc.
The stock decline was due to the constriction in state school
budgets to buy and replace old chalk boards. Iconix Brand
Group, Inc. despite its impressive longer-term track record,
experienced a decline of 15% in its stock price in 2011. Since
2008, revenue has grown at a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of
about 19%, while during the same time, free cash flow has
positively compounded at 27% during a terrible economic period. The
stock, based on its year-end price, is trading at only 6.5 times
2012 estimate of free cash flow of $2.50 per share, the Portfolio
Sub-Advisor believes this company continues to have great potential
to grow.
The largest individual contributors to performance during the past
12 months were Six Flags Entertainment Corp., CVS Caremark Corp.
and Iron Mountain Inc. Six Flags Entertainment Corp., which the
Portfolio Sub-Advisor bought mid-year, gained almost 36% and was
the largest contributor to the Fund's returns in 2011. Despite
tough economic times, families continue to attend amusement parks
as it represents an affordable vacation. CVS Caremark Corp.
represents the largest dispenser of pharmaceuticals in the U.S. The
company has projected earnings growth of 10-15% over the next five
years, driven by a rapidly aging population, a host of drugs coming
off patent, "Obamacare", and increasing adherence of patients
taking their medications. Iron Mountain Inc. was sold at a healthy
profit to the Fund because of the entry of a private equity firm
that forced the company to change its activities. At the sale
price, the Portfolio Sub-Advisor felt the stock was more than
reflecting its future prospects.
Nothing in the above report should be considered a
recommendation to buy or sell a particular security. Securities
discussed within may have been sold since the date of this
publication. Commissions, trailing commissions, management fees and
expenses all may be associated with mutual fund investments. Please
read the prospectus before investing. Mutual funds are not
guaranteed, their values change frequently and past performance may
not be repeated. The IA Clarington Funds and IA Clarington Target
Click Funds are managed by IA Clarington Investments Inc. IA
Clarington and the IA Clarington logo are trademarks of Industrial
Alliance Insurance and Financial Services Inc. and are used under
license. It should not be assumed that any of the securities
translations or holdings discussed were or will prove to be
profitable, or that the investment decisions made in the future
will be profitable or equal the investment performance of the
securities discussed herein. The information contained above is
portfolio manager's viewpoint and may include estimates,
projections and other "forward-looking statements." Actual events
may differ substantially from those presented herein.