Canadian Small Cap Class Commentary
Portfolio Advisor: QV Investors Inc.
Fund Commentary - December 31, 2011
Over the past 12 months, equity markets have been volatile with
a downward bias as the global economic recovery that was set in
motion several years ago faced a plethora of headwinds. An
intensifying European sovereign credit crisis, softer global
economic data, the U.S. debt-ceiling debacle, the "Arab Spring" and
a growing Occupy movement provided abundant ammunition to alarm
investors. Correlation among stocks reached near record levels,
with daily stock price fluctuations increasingly driven by changes
in macro sentiment rather than underlying company fundamentals.
The Portfolio Sub-Advisor kept the Fund well-diversified
throughout the year. This benefitted relative performance. The
benchmark, BMO Nesbitt Burns Small Cap Index, is highly
concentrated in the resource sectors, with Materials and Energy
making up in excess of 50% of the index. Weakness in the benchmark
over the past 12 months was driven by declines in the Materials and
Energy sectors with returns of -28.8% and -20.3% respectively. The
Fund maintained a combined weight of roughly 26.1% in these two
sectors, holding a bias towards investments in more defensive
business models such as energy infrastructure, packagers and wood
pole manufacturing. As a result, the Fund was able to generate
gains in both of these sectors. The Fund's recent outperformance in
the resource sectors explains the majority of total outperformance
during the past year when compared to the benchmark. An overweight
position in Consumer Staples was also a large contributor to Fund
outperformance.
The largest individual contributors to performance during the
past 12 months were AltaGas Ltd., The Jean Coutu Group (PJC) Inc.,
and Argonaut Gold Inc. AltaGas Ltd. benefited from increased
investor demand for yield, continued success in the execution of
its growth strategy and improving Alberta power prices. The Jean
Coutu Group (PJC) Inc. benefited from increased investor demand
after demonstrating stable cash flow generation and dividend growth
despite recently enacted provincial drug reforms. Argonaut Gold
Inc. benefited from continued success from mine operations and
exploration, as well as a higher gold price.
The largest detractor to Fund performance from a sector
perspective was in the Financials space, where the biggest negative
contributors were E-L Financial Corp. Ltd., GMP Capital Inc. and
Transcontinental Inc. The current low interest rate environment
negatively impacted E-L Financial Corp. Ltd.'s life insurance
division. Despite this headwind, the company remains well
capitalized and the current share price does not appear to
recognize the value associated with E-L Financial Corp. Ltd.'s
other businesses and corporate investments. GMP Capital Inc. is one
of Canada's largest independent brokerage firms. Recent weakness in
capital markets has taken a toll on the company's profitability and
share price performance. Transcontinental Inc. is Canada's largest,
most profitable printing company. Despite challenging end-markets,
the company has maintained strong margins and cash flow. The
manager believes that E-L Financial Corp. Ltd., GMP Capital Inc.
and Transcontinental Inc. have proven records of navigating through
difficult environments and remains committed to these
investments.
Additions to the Fund over the past year include: The Jean Coutu
Group (PJC) Inc. and MacDonald, Dettwiler and Associates Ltd.
(MDA). The Jean Coutu Group (PJC) Inc. is one of Canada's largest
and most profitable drugstore operators. The company's Canadian
operations have experienced significant and consistent growth over
the past 10 years, with revenues more than doubling and operating
profits compounding at a double-digit annual rate. MDA is a leader
in providing space based information systems and geospatial
services. The company has accumulated a high degree of engineering
expertise in this very technical industry and has a long track
record of generating returns on capital investment at above market
rates. The Portfolio Sub-Advisor believes these companies have
sustainable business models and expects them to provide reasonable
returns over the business cycle. During the past year, the
Portfolio Sub-Advisor eliminated positions in Glacier Media Inc.,
Le Château Inc., Savanna Energy Services Corp. and Vermilion Energy
Inc.